BackJudiciary
Supreme Court refuses judicial review of collegium's Justice Nisha Banu transfer decision
The Supreme Court of India ruled that its collegium's recommendation to transfer Justice J. Nisha Banu from Madras High Court to Kerala High Court cannot be subject to judicial review. This came amid delays in her assuming the new post, leading to a presidential directive setting a December 20, 2025 deadline.
Why It Matters
Highlights tensions between judicial independence, collegium system authority, and executive enforcement of transfers, potentially setting precedent on judge compliance and review limits.
Timeline
9 Events
Lok Sabha raises transfer query
December 12, 2025
Congress MP questioned Law Minister in Lok Sabha on Justice Banu's collegium role post-transfer; government emphasized constitutional framework.[5]
President directs assumption of charge
December 12, 2025
President, after CJI consultation, directed Justice Banu to assume Kerala High Court charge by or before December 20, 2025, via official notification.[1][2][3][4][5][7]
CJI consults on leave extension
December 2025
Justice Banu sought leave extension till December 20 via Tamil Nadu Governor's office; CJI learned of non-adherence and wrote to President urging deadline.[2][5]
Lawyers raise judicial indiscipline concerns
December 2025
Lawyers from Madras High Court wrote to President, CJI, and others alleging judicial indiscipline due to non-compliance with transfer.[4]
Justice Banu on leave post-transfer
October 2025
Justice Banu went on earned leave from Madras High Court after transfer notification and did not assume charge in Kerala.[2][4][6]
One source notes notification
October 13, 2025
Announcement of transfer to Kerala High Court reported.[6]
Centre notifies transfer
October 14, 2025
The Union Government notified Justice Banu's transfer from Madras to Kerala High Court, two months before presidential directive.[2][4][5][6]
One source notes collegium recommendation
August 26, 2025
A report states the collegium recommended the transfer on August 26, 2025.[6]
Supreme Court Collegium recommends transfer
August 27, 2025
The Supreme Court Collegium recommended transferring Justice J. Nisha Banu, third senior-most judge at Madras High Court, to Kerala High Court as part of 14 transfers.[2][4]