BackJudiciary
Supreme Court of India rules judicial hierarchy cannot guide statutory interpretations
The Supreme Court of India, in a judgment on November 10, 2025, reaffirmed judicial discipline and held that judicial hierarchy does not permit lower courts to deviate from Supreme Court precedents on statutory interpretation, overturning a Bombay High Court decision.
Why It Matters
This ruling reinforces the supremacy of Supreme Court precedents under Article 141, ensuring uniformity in law interpretation, judicial discipline, and preventing forum shopping or inconsistent outcomes across courts.
Timeline
2 Events
Supreme Court sets aside Bombay High Court judgment
10 November 2025
Bench of Justices Vikram Nath and Prasanna B. Varale sets aside the High Court judgment as contrary to binding precedent in Godrej & Boyce, emphasizing judicial discipline, respect for precedents, and that judicial hierarchy cannot guide statutory interpretations differently.
Bombay High Court delivers judgment
27 September 2018
Bombay High Court holds that private forests in Maharashtra vested in the State on 30 August 1975 under Maharashtra Private Forests (Acquisition) Act, invalidating later claims and transactions.